Who Benefits from IoT?
Cui Bono is not Irish for Paul David Hewson. It does not ask about Cher’s late ex-husband.
It’s Latin, and means “who benefits?”
Old TV detectives ask, “who benefits from the murder?” The Roman Republic asked, “Cui Bono?” and guessed whoever benefited was probably guilty.
What does this have to do with IoT? Plenty.
Cui Bono is not asked enough.
Reading about the Internet of Things (IoT) or the Industrial IoT (IIoT) you find many benefits (bono), but not much on who (cui) benefits. A flaw in some IoT schemes is a disconnect between who pays and who benefits. The question helps avoid traps.
Think about consumer wearables.
Who benefits; a person wearing the device. Who pays for the device and bandwidth; same person. Most wearables harvest data for other purposes. So, original equipment manufacturers (OEMs) benefit too. They profit on the devices, and don’t pay for bandwidth.
This business model has risk. The EU GDPR says you must disclose what you are doing with data, including transparent explanation of your algorithms. In the U.S., Lone Star’s research suggests the same thing; people believe they have a “right to transparency.”
You can understand this sentiment. If I pay for a device, and for data transport, why does someone else benefit? Who owns the data? https://www.lone-star.com/who-owns-your-data-2/
Leveraging other people’s assets, data, and effort is a core idea in Silicon Valley. It’s the basis of Facebook (users create content). It’s Uber’s core (drivers pay for cars and insurance).
Time will tell how consumer IoT works this out. Nest™ promises not to use thermostat data for most purposes ( https://nest.com/privacy-faq/ ). But Nest needs IoT data to tune algorithms; they benefit. They hope you believe you benefit from their improvements.
A question consumer IoT rarely considers is, “Who pays for failure?”
An IoT solution needing too much bandwidth may be returned or thrown away. Consumers self-select. Not serving 100% of them is ok.
IIoT is different; an entire logistics fleet needs to work, or, pneumatic systems in a thousand factories around the globe; it’s all or nothing.
Industrial value chains are complex. One chain may have an OEM, user, owner, and service providers. Some are in tension with others. Six to ten separate parties are all asking “Cui Bono?”, even if they don’t speak Latin.
Consumer IoT Cui Bono is simple compared to IIoT.
Some people claim industrial OEMs should source IIoT implementations. OEMs should make smart products, as auto makers have. But my smart car and dealer service department don’t agree on service intervals. Cui Bono?
Leased truck and construction equipment fleets are examples of “things” owned by one firm and used by another. Should users pay for data shipped to owners? Not if only owners benefit. In IoT trials of this kind of equipment, antennas are “accidently” broken. Cui Bono?
Even if corporations agree, workers can object to big brother data collection; more mysterious “accidents” happen. Cui Bono?
To devise great IIoT solutions ask:
- What connectivity exists where industrial “things” are used?
- What costs and permissions are needed to access connectivity?
- What cyber vulnerability is created by the connections?
- Who pays for the costs, permissions and risks?
- What new value is created?
- Cui Bono?
So, for IoT success, and in particular for IIoT, we suggest three things:
- Ask “Cui Bono?”
- Ask who pays?
- Work with Lone Star; our Latin Motto is “Semper Creando Valorum” (always create value)
Or, if you don’t want to think about all this, just listen to Bono; the Irish one.
About Lone Star Analysis
Lone Star Analysis enables customers to make insightful decisions faster than their competitors. We are a predictive guide bridging the gap between data and action. Prescient insights support confident decisions for customers in Oil & Gas, Transportation & Logistics, Industrial Products & Services, Aerospace & Defense, and the Public Sector.
Lone Star delivers fast time to value supporting customers planning and on-going management needs. Utilizing our TruNavigator® software platform, Lone Star brings proven modeling tools and analysis that improve customers top line, by winning more business, and improve the bottom line, by quickly enabling operational efficiency, cost reduction, and performance improvement. Our trusted AnalyticsOSSM software solutions support our customers’ real-time predictive analytics needs when continuous operational performance optimization, cost minimization, safety improvement, and risk reduction are important.
Headquartered in Dallas, Texas, Lone Star is found on the web at http://www.Lone-Star.com